What would Valentine’s Day be without a heart-shaped treat to share with your sweetie? We’ve rounded up the cutest, yummiest treats to celebrate Valentine’s Day. From sweet to savory, you’ll want to share these with the ones you love (or keep them for yourself!).

The Bagel Nook
51 Village Center Dr. Freehold
301 N. Harrison St. Princeton
Pre-order your heart bagels at the Princeton and Freehold locations — then just add butter or cream cheese for a perfect Valentine’s Day breakfast!


301 N Harrison St, Princeton
LiLLiPiES (@lillipies)

These pecan Linzer cookies filled with house-made strawberry jam are a great way to show your love!

Three Daughters

1875 Springfield Ave, Maplewood

Three Daughters Baking (@threedaughtersbakingco)

From Cake for 2 with pink rosettes and a vanilla heart cookie on top to the sweetest Valentine’s Day cupcakes featuring vanilla icing on vanilla cake or chocolate on chocolate your sweetheart will swoon with a sugar rush.


Krispy Kreme
Multiple locations throughout NJ
These yummy heart-shaped donuts are dipped, sprinkled and filled with cake batter creme. They’re only available through February 14 so get them now!

Jules Thin Crust

18 Witherspoon Street, Princeton

Jules Thin Crust (@julesthincrust)

Forget dinner and go straight for this heart-shaped strawberry Nutella pie, available at all Jules locations.

Baking Mama

88 Hudson St., Hoboken

Baking Mama (@iambakingmama)

The sugar cookies here are sweet enough to win anyone’s heart.


Carlo’s Bakery

95 Washington St., Hoboken

Carlo’s Bakery (@carlosbakery)

This Valentine Chocolate Mousse Cake has Love written all over it. Perfect for the chocolate lover in your life!


Louisa’s Chocolate Bar

106 Jackson St, Cape May

Louisa’s Chocolate Bar (@louisaschocolate)

Ok, so they may not be heart-shaped but these red peppermint macarons still win out over flowers every time!

PJ’s Pancake House

4581 NJ-27, Kingston

PJ’s Pancake House (@pjspancakehouse)

PJ’s just took things to the next level with heart-shaped macarons. We think we’re in love! Available at their Kingston bakery.



Napoli’s Pizza

1118 Washington St., Hoboken

Napoli’s Pizza (@napolishoboken)

A heart-shaped pizza is a perfect way to show a loved one you care – with cheese!


Novino Ristorante

64 Ramapo Valley Rd, Mahwah

Novino (@novinonj)

Love will be in the air – and on your plate – when you order a heart-shaped pie from Novino’s. Toppings are extra, but isn’t he worth it?


Café Panache

130 E Main St, Ramsey

CAFÉ PANACHE (@cafepanache)

Heart-shaped filet mignon ravioli is out of this world – beet juice gives the dish its red coloring.


Plated by D

53 S. Main St., Lodi

PlatedbyD LLC (@platedbyd)

Show your love with flowers this February 14 – that is, beautiful meat flowers from Plated by D.


Rockin’ Roots

434 Hillsdale Ave, Hillsdale

Rockin Roots (@rockin_roots_juice)

Drop a love bomb on your sweetie with these cocoa bombs and cordial bombs guaranteed to make a big impression.

Ferraro’s Italian Food Specialties

166 Halsey Road, Parsippany

Cooking With Dana (@ferraros_italianspecialties)

Your love isn’t cheesy, but these heart-shaped raviolis are! Light a fire, pour some wine and make the most romantic dinner your Valentine has ever experienced!

Everything Bagel

483 NJ-17 S, Paramus

Everything Bagel (@everythingbagelparamus)

Wake your Valentine up to strong coffee and heart-shaped bagels from here and the day is sure to be a success!


See What Our Readers Are Saying